BankID
Unsolicited case study I did for BankID, it’s a well known identification service provider in Sweden.
the brand
Should you even touch a well established brand like BankID?
I get it. Change is hard and a lot of brands are getting redesigned just for the sake of redesign. It’s easy to say a brand/logo can be done ‘better’ from a design perspective. But most (re)designers forget that a logo is such an important part of a brand. Making a logo minimalistic, ‘better’ or more modern can have a massive impact on the brand. Designers and agencies should be more aware of that and step away from fancy rebrandings and go back to the essence of the rebranding process.
Rebranding is a lot more than making the logo match the latest design trends.
A few examples of how ‘lazy’ logo redesigns can impact a brand. You can take away the entire identity of a company and even make clients rethink how they feel about the brand.
About BankID
Early on in your migration process you learn about a little thing called BankID. It’s supposed to be the golden key to a lot of Swedish services but ‘fy fan’ is it hard to get! You need a bank account and a bank willing to provide you with a BankID. After that, BankID is basically the N°1 app on your phone. You use it at least 10 times a day to open apps, websites, mailboxes and so on… I have tons of respect for the science and code behind it and the people making sure that thing run flawless. If BankID has a sick day, Sweden has a sick day.
BankID is a great brand. I mean… Their logo is recognizable. It’s clean, scaleable and easy to implement, it’s not a bad logo, not at all!
The problem with the BankID brand is that it is so well established that nobody questions it. Every Swede gets a BankID when they hit puberty… It’s a part of their DNA. But I’m not a Swede. I’m an ‘invandare’. So I look at Swedish things with different eyes. So here’s my take on the institute that is BankID. With the eyes of a clueless Belgian designer.
the problem
It’s not because it’s good, that it can’t be better.
Ok, time to be honest. I just don’t get the logo. I mean, it’s an ‘i’ and a ‘d’, I’m not stupid. I just don’t get the iconography. To me it resembles a puzzle. Like pieces fitting together. BankID is the piece to the puzzle that is your life? If I had a company called ID Puzzles I would have gladly paid big bucks for a logo like this though. In all honesty, it’s a clever design!
I’m also a little distracted by the middle part. Is it a ‘P’? Is it a cute giraffe? Designers should never underestimate the power of negative space! I don’t know, I just don’t get it. Clueless Belgian remember?
PS: I’m sorry because you can’t unsee it…
Last but not least, there’s the shape of the puzzle piece. I don’t know why, but it resembles an old scale weight. You know, one of those old brass things people used to weigh stuff. But… Aren’t those weights old and not so trustworthy?
the new logo
Going back to what the brand stands for.
I went to the drawing board with these important key points in mind:
Keep it recognisable
BankID operates in a very scam-sensitive field and you don’t want to spook existing customers with a completely different logo.
Keep it simple
It’s good now. Rescaleable and easy to implement. Don’t mess with things that are ok.
Get rid of the slant!
I hate the slant, sorry. I assume it has to represent movement or something but to me it feels like the tipping tower of Pisa. Something that’s going to fall over every second. Not the vibe BankID is going for I guess.
Untill another know-it-all designer like me proves me wrong I think this is a nice step forward for the brand. It’s not perfect, nothing is, but it’s a refinement of what was already good. It’s an evolution, not a revolution.
Connecting humans, not puzzle pieces. The rounded corner on the right figure suggests that they put their arm around the other one. But hey, if I have to explain it it’s probably not worth mentioning.
The more rounded shapes help to give the logo a less sturdy and industrial look. It’s all about embracing the curves. I could write a whole blogpost on the psychology of sharp corners and how they affect how people perceive your brand but that’s for another time.
That’s it… No more fancy hidden stuff. I mean, how many secrets can you hide in a good logo? I’ll leave that to the complot theorists. Ok, I hid a giraffe somewhere…
Just a nice, simple and recognisable logo!
the app
Examining the existing app
The current homepage feels clean and intuïtive. The team managed to focus on the essential info and got rid of distracting features and information. Primary actions are placed well into the reachable area.
It lacks a little hierarchy though. Both visual and funtional. The logo has a very prominent position and features all get the same ‘value’. Scanning action has more focus but doesn’t feel like a primary action. News and warning text gets a little lost in the ‘void’.
© This image is a screenshot of BankID’s app. I do not own the rights to images or copywriting in any way. All rights belong to BankID.
redesigning the app
Optimizing both UI and UX but keeping the app fast and recognisable
By resizing the logo the design does not only feel less overwhelming, it takes away the main focus from the logo. Since users already opened the app we may assume they know they’re using BankID so the importance of a prominent logo loses value.
Moving the account / settings action to a different location makes it stand out from other actions more specific to the app. The account / settings action is a very common action and should therefore be placed in more ‘familiar’ place.
Notifications are better aligned. They are placed in the optimal viewing area but do not hinder the primary actions. Giving it a ‘close’ button creates interaction by the user and enlarges the chance that people actually read these notifications.
The primary action – scanning a code – is now way more prominent. It has the focus and contrast it needs. Also for users with visual impairment. Users are directly focussed on this action and have no eye fatigue looking for the feature.
Secondary actions have a defined UI style more in line with the traditional but well known tab/nav bar. Icons have a similar overall style and feel more consistent throughout the app. Secondary actions are also placed in the optimal tap region.
dark mode
Creating a dark version that pops
Dark mode is not just a color inversion. Its a well designed version of the app that is easier on the eyes without sacrificing contrast to those who need it. It has the same benefits as the light mode but with its own ‘dark mode perks’.
contact
Reach out and say hi!
I decided to delete my social media accounts a long time ago. What you might want to know about me: I truly enjoy walks with my dog, spending time with my friends & family, travelling the world and watching a good show or movie. Would you like to connect, instead of scrolling through the details of my everyday life? Let’s grab a coffee and we’ll have a deep, meaningful conversation about the things that excite, scare and inspire us…
I occasionally use Linkedin as a freelancer to get in contact with companies. Don't expect me to be an 'influencer' but feel free to reach out or connect to talk about interesting opportunities.
say hello
about
work
contact
resume
Wim Mees commv
BTW - BE 0793970833
IBAN - BE96 7340 6598 8705